Skip to Content
Buyer's Guide

Ultrasonic or PD?
What 15 years of field data shows.

MIG sells both ultrasonic and positive displacement meters, so we don't need you to pick one. We need you to pick the right one. Here is what the longest side-by-side field study in the industry found, in plain terms.

The study

Same homes. Both meter types. Since 2010.

The Johnson Controls Static Meter Research Project, led by Craig C. Hannah, P.E., has tracked billed usage on static (ultrasonic and electromagnetic) and PD meters installed on the same residential services since December 2010. The guide analyzes that data across three U.S. utilities and 39 services.

What it found

The results by water type.

+0.96%
Soft water, 5/8 x 3/4 inPD meters registered 0.96% more water than ultrasonic over about 14 years (Salisbury, NC).
+0.32%
Hard water, 5/8 inAfter 15+ years, 0.32% in favor of PD over electromagnetic meters (Olathe, KS).
+3.88%
Very hard water, full 3/4 inUltrasonic registered 3.88% more: the one clear static advantage in the study (Glendale, CA).

At standard residential sizes the revenue difference is about $2 to $4 per meter per year. Replacement cycles, battery life and purchase price drive the real cost.

What it means for your utility

How we'd choose.

  • Standard 5/8 x 3/4 inch services: a well-built brass PD meter holds its own on billed water and usually costs less over 40 years. See PD meters
  • Very hard water and larger services: ultrasonic earns its place where low-flow capture and no moving parts matter most. See large ultrasonic meters
  • Battery life: the 20-year figure assumes ideal conditions. Realistic life is roughly 15 years with a separate radio, 12 with an integrated RF radio and 10 with integrated cellular, and the whole meter is replaced at battery end of life.
  • Pilot first: run your own side-by-side test before a large purchase. We can help set it up.
Questions

Ultrasonic vs. PD FAQ.

Are ultrasonic water meters more accurate than PD meters?

Ultrasonic meters register lower flows than PD meters, but in 15 years of side-by-side field data at the standard 5/8 x 3/4 inch size, PD meters registered as much or more billed water in both soft and hard water. Static meters showed a clear advantage only with full 3/4 inch meters in very hard water.

Does hard water affect ultrasonic meter accuracy?

Yes. Scale on transducers and reflectors changes the acoustic signal path. At Glendale, CA (205 ppm), the gap between ultrasonic and PD meters peaked at 8.86% in 2019 and then narrowed, consistent with scale eventually affecting both meter types.

How long do ultrasonic meter batteries last?

Roughly 15 years with a separate radio, 12 years with an integrated RF radio and 10 years with an integrated cellular radio, versus a 20-year figure that assumes ideal conditions.

Which is cheaper over 40 years?

For standard residential meters, the guide's 40-year model shows 2 PD replacements versus 3 to 4 ultrasonic replacements, a PD savings of about $175 to $340 per meter depending on endpoint configuration.

Get the full 50-page guide.

Every claim sourced, every limitation stated. Free download.